%20(1).png)
Build it up
You are kindly requested to revise your manuscript and submit the updated version to PFDM 2025 before 15-06-2025.
Below, you will find all relevant review comments from:
-
Scientific Committee,
-
Track Leaders,
-
The Editorial Team
Please consider these carefully in preparing your revised manuscript.Once your revisions are complete, you may submit the updated version using the submission link provided at the bottom of this page.We appreciate your contributions and look forward to receiving your revised manuscript.
Development of Traffic Noise Propagation Model for Engineering Education
Reviewer's feedback:
The paper is very clear and well organised, providing the necessary level of details. Despite the modelling of road noise barriers by FEM is not new, the approach combining a real case study, numerical simulation calibrated on field experiments in the frame of an education project is very interesting. Two detail remarks: a few sentences could be added on the critical adaptation of the mesh to the frequency (what frequency range was considered, what implication on the mesh refinment...) and captions in the figures should be enlarged for better readability.
Editorial Decision for Conference Proceedings:
No additinional comments!
Track Leader’s Comments (if any):
Please note that some of the track leader’s comments are intended as feedback for future improvements
There are several other noise propagation models. For the paper to be valuable the authors should add a comparison with those, and indicate the advantage(s) of the proposed new model. If such a discussion is added and would show that the new model is indeed better, then an extended version is worth publication in a journal, but not in its present contents.